"Aux Malconsorts - Christiane" 1er Cru de Vosne Romanée 2012
The harvest began September 17 and continued through the end of the month.
Recalling the 2012 vintage brings on two different sentiments. For one, there is the great satisfaction to have an excellent vintage in terms of quality, especially in red. For another, there is the profound disappointment of tiny yields accompanied by the hail devastation of many vines, from Santenay up to Pommard. The weather was difficult at the beginning of the season but improved around mid-July, which saved the quality of the vintage. Concerning the yields, they are very low, and everything that could have contributed to lowering them happened in 2012: small flowering, poor fruit set, uneven berry size...and unfortunately, hail.
The aromas have a rare complexity and elegance. They offer an astonishing bouquet of spices, cherry pits, black fruits, dried flowers, musk and hard candies. The textures are simultaneously dense and ethereal. The attacks are brisk and the mid-palates are etheral and lengthy. The tannins are soft and well-wrapped in intense fruit that vascilates between tangy and sweet. The suave finishes offer refreshment and persistence.
We left two-thirds whole clusters in Beaune Perrières, Beaune Grèves and Volnay Mitans and 100% in Volnay Les Taillepieds, Corton Clos du Roi and all the Côte de Nuits cuvées, including in our village level Nuits-St-Georges « Les Saints-Juliens ». These are all wines to age for at least ten years, even 20-25 years for the Grand Crus and « Grand » Premier Crus from the Côte de Nuits.
This is quite rare, but we have found slight reduction in most of the wines. As such, we advise to decant them about one hour if they are being tasted before they reach ten years old.
-The nose is in almost the exact same state as the straight cuvée with its reductive and floral aromas. There is a slightly finer mouth feel to the equally large-scaled flavors where the supporting tannins are notably fine-grained that imparts a different texture, particularly on the superbly complex and highly persistent finish. I very much like the overall sense of harmony and depth and as good as the regular cuvée is there is just another dimension present here. In a word, marvelous.
Score: 93-95 Tasted: Apr 15, 2014 Drink: 2024+ Issue: 54 Outstanding - Allen Meadows
- Their other plot, also 100% whole bunch and given 60% new oak.
Looks a little deeper than the other bottling. Rounder and rich and sweeter than the other bottling. A bit more tannic. A little more user-friendly and more obviously fruity. Score : 18 Jancis Robinson